Start with a defensible safe zone that has a reachable entrance and enough nearby coverage to protect the approach. Use the map layout and the starting crowd locations to decide how much space to enclose. There is no single best zone size across the reported player examples.

Compare compact zones and longer routes
A compact perimeter can leave more resources for defenses outside the walls. A larger outline may cover more civilians or buildings, but it also creates more wall and more possible approaches to watch. Players in the Steam strategy thread report success with different layouts, so treat them as setups to try.
Change one thing after a failed run
If civilians stop short, check the route into the gate before expanding the whole perimeter. If zombies break through, note where they crossed and try moving some coverage to that approach. Compare the civilian outcome and whether you eliminated the zombies before choosing your next change.